top of page

Blood Brother

Nov 12
8 min read

Updated: Nov 13

In Toldot, Rivkah, wife of Isaac, delivers twins whose struggle begins within her womb. The elder is Esav. And grasping his heel is Jacob, who will secure a birthright that seems to belong to Esav but not earned by him. The story of the sale unfolds, according to Seder Olam, when the boys are fifteen years old. Rashi reveals that it happens the very same day Avraham died.


The birthright transaction foreshadows one of the most misunderstood narratives in the Torah—the so-called “stolen blessing.”


That blessing takes place decades after Esav sells his birthright to Jacob. This episode begins when Isaac, feeling the effects of old age and uncertain how much longer he will live, decides it is time to bestow a blessing on his firstborn.


What could have caused him to dwell on the transience of life?


Rashi explains that Isaac was within four years of his mother Sarah’s age at her death. Isaac will live to the age of 180 (Genesis 35:28).


In addition to his advanced age, Isaac was blind. His failing eyesight was real, but it also carries a symbolic reading. In an earlier verse, the Torah describes the relationship between Esav and his father that became a stumbling block:


“Isaac loved Esav because game was in his mouth, but Rivkah loved Jacob.”

                                                     — Genesis 25:28


Rashi reads the reference to Esav’s mouth as an allusion to his ability to ensnare his father with words. Isaac asked Esav to take up his hunting gear, bring home game, and prepare his favorite food so that he could bless him.


Esav answered his father’s call with hineni, usually translated as “Here I am.”


This expression appears at other crucial turning points in the Torah, including the Akedah.


At this point in the narrative, we need to ask why Esav chose the wrong path?

As wayward as he was, Esav still had free will. Consider the influence of family figures close at hand, whose lives offered towering examples of spiritual greatness:


Avraham—a man who argued with God for justice, and a grandfather whose life exemplified chesed, (lovingkindness), and gevurah, (strength) in service of the Divine.

Isaac had survived the Akedah, carried that spiritual inheritance, and understood the weight of the blessing.


Esav could have channeled his strength and intelligence into the same spiritual inheritance that was just within his reach, but he chose not to transcend his nature.

He clung to the material, the sensual. Esav yearned for what he perceived as greatness in the example of a figure known in Torah as, “a mighty hunter before the Lord.”


Following Abraham’s death years earlier, Esau ambushed and killed King Nimrod, then fled back to his father’s house in exhaustion and fear of Nimrod’s men. Convinced he was about to die that day, Esau sold both his birthright( and his share in the Cave of Machpelah)to Jacob.


We now come back to the narrative of the blessing Isaac would bestow. Rav Samson Raphael Hirsch explains that Isaac’s promise to bless Esav for carrying out his request was more than a reward for a good deed. Isaac hoped that Esav would realize that his physical skills—for that matter, any skill—could be elevated in the service of God through an act of kindness.


Mother Rivkah knew it was time to act.


She summoned Jacob, telling him to bring two young goats from their flock. She would prepare a tasty meal and wanted Jacob to serve the food to his father and receive the blessing, instead of Esav. When Jacob objected, his mother assured him, “Upon me be your curse, my son.”


She could speak with confidence. The reader will recall what God had told her while she still carried the boys in her womb:


“And the elder shall serve the younger.” — Genesis 25:23


We can imagine those prophetic words echoing in Rivkah’s ears as she dressed Jacob in Esav’s choice garments. According to Midrashic tradition, God had fashioned them for Adam. The royal finery was later stolen by Cush, who gave the clothing to Nimrod—and later taken by Esav after killing him.


The masquerade was complete when Rivkah covered Jacob’s hands and the smooth part of his neck with the skins of the young goats (Genesis 27:15–16).


Jacob announces his arrival.


At this point, Rashi finds a subtle distinction beneath the apparent meaning of Jacob’s words. A straightforward translation of Genesis 27:19 reads, “I am Esav your firstborn.” Rashi interprets the sentence in two parts: Jacob identifies himself as the one bringing the food, then pauses to state that Esav is Isaac’s first born.


Jacob’s words contain a deliberate ambiguity.


Isaac asked him to come closer. He had expected Esav, yet when Jacob drew near, Isaac sensed that something was amiss:

“The voice is Jacob’s voice, but the hands are the hands of Esav.” — Genesis 27:22


According to Rashi, Jacob’s manner of expression—his courteous speech and reference to God—distinguished him from Esav. Jacob approached, and Isaac smelled the fragrance of his garments.


The blessing compared his son’s fragrance to that of a field blessed by God and promised the dew of heaven, the richness of the earth, abundant grain and wine, and authority among peoples and brothers. It concluded:


“Cursed be those who curse you, and blessed be those who bless you.”

— Genesis 27:29


We may ask how Isaac could have been so easily deceived.


The Torah does not record Rivkah telling him the prophetic words she had received decades earlier, while the twins were still in her womb. Ramban explicitly considers why she had not told him. Those words were:


“Two nations are in your womb, and two peoples shall separate from within you; one people shall be stronger than the other, and the elder shall serve the younger.”

                                                       — Genesis 25:23


Her ruse reads like a poor charade because it was likely the purpose. Could Rivkah have expected a savory repast and hairy coverings to deceive her husband completely?


Perhaps her masquerade gently exposed how easily outward appearances can be deceiving just as Esav’s constant sanctimonious façade had done precisely that.

Rivkah may have used this bit of theater to prevent Esav from receiving the blessing while providing Isaac a way to bestow it upon Jacob.


This might explain Isaac’s willingness to proceed despite his doubts.

The Torah says his subsequent trembling shows that the outcome shook him profoundly.


By distinguishing Jacob’s voice from Esav’s hands, Isaac also gives us an image of Israel’s mission. The survival of Am Yisrael requires external qualities such as strength, daring, and boldness—qualities associated with Esav that can be put to positive use. At the same time, Israel must speak with the voice of Jacob, expressing the teachings of Torah. Jacob, who will become Israel, receives a blessing that can unite a holy purpose with the physical strength necessary to establish a nation and become an example to the other nations of the earth.


There, in the quiet warmth of Isaac’s dwelling, on the occasion that tradition identifies with Pesach, something monumental had taken place. Rashi, drawing on Midrash, identifies the fragrance Isaac perceived with Gan Eden. This reference sends the reader back through the centuries to Adam and Chavah (Eve).


There is a direct association between their fall and the blessing given to Jacob.


Both events share common elements, but their outcomes differ. God had forbidden Adam to eat from the Tree of Knowledge of Good and Evil. The words of the nachash, the serpent, led Chavah to question the divine command. She took the forbidden fruit and gave some to Adam, who also ate. Their eyes were opened. Before sending them out of the Garden, God fashioned garments of skin for them. He also told Chavah that she would experience pain in bearing children.


The anguish associated with childbearing invites a connection with Rivkah’s distress during her pregnancy. The parallel extends to a mother whose sons become rivals, with the younger brother’s life endangered by the elder. These are thoughtful, prescient women understood as spiritual counterparts. Chavah was deceived; Rivkah employed deception in an effort to open her husband’s eyes to an error.


We find the connection developed explicitly in the teachings of the Arizal, preserved in Sefer HaLikutim. Rivkah’s intervention is understood as a tikkun—a repair—of Chavah’s act.


Where Chavah’s action brought a curse upon Adam, Rivkah’s brought blessing to Jacob. The published adaptation states: “By being a conduit of blessing, Rebecca rectified the sin of Eve.”


The language of listening makes the reversal especially striking. God tells Adam, “Because you listened to your wife’s voice” (Genesis 3:17); Rivkah tells Jacob, “Now, my son, listen to my voice”.


In the Arizal’s teaching, the second act of listening participates in repairing the first. Rivkah’s assurance, “Upon me be your curse, my son” belongs to that same pattern.


The dramatic impact of this intervention was immense. Within this reading, God’s plan for humanity took a great leap forward.


Chavah yielded to doubt about the Creator’s command, but Rivkah held His words in her heart, determined that the spiritual mantle would pass to the worthy son, Jacob. In this mystical reading, Jacob joined his mother in rectifying the sin of Adam and Chavah.


The serpent’s deception was answered through deception, middah keneged middah—measure for measure—so that blessing could emerge where deception had once brought a curse. That measure-for-measure formulation expresses the pattern.


When Esav returned and discovered that Jacob had already received the blessing, he cried out in anguish. He accused Jacob of taking both his birthright and his blessing, passing over his own willing sale of the birthright for bread and lentil stew.

We can hear echoes of Esav’s complaint through the centuries in the spiritual heirs of Edom. Rabbinic literature associates Esav–Edom with Rome; its extension to later Western civilization belongs to the history of Jewish interpretation. There is another echo of Amalek—Esav’s grandson—in movements bent upon Israel’s destruction.


This is a moral and theological comparison, rather than a claim about their biological ancestry. For me, the savagery of October 7, 2023, makes the ancient threat against Israel painfully immediate.


Thank God, Jacob was given the name Israel.


The nation named for him is called God’s firstborn (Exodus 4:22). The birthright sale and the blessing are related episodes, but they are not identical. Later, knowing precisely whom he is addressing, Isaac explicitly grants Jacob the blessing of Avraham and the inheritance of the land (Genesis 28:1–4).


The blessing bestowed upon Jacob can thus be understood as a kind of rebirth, anticipating the emergence of a nation with a divine calling:

“Let peoples serve you, and nations bow down to you. Be master over your brothers, and let your mother’s sons bow down to you. Cursed be those who curse you, and blessed be those who bless you.” — Genesis 27:29


By accepting this noble calling, Jacob helped advance the restoration of the purpose first revealed in Gan Eden: humanity serving the Creator here on earth, with Israel eventually called to be a kingdom of priests (Exodus 19:6). Genesis 2:15 places Adam in the Garden to work it and guard it; this links to the original service of humanity to Israel’s later priestly calling.


The struggle between brothers supplies the other half of the reversal. Bereshit Rabbah 22:8 explains that Abel and Cain got into an argument which turned into a wrestling match. But Abel was stronger than Cain. To gain the upper hand, Cain begged for mercy. Abel took pity and let him go.


The Midrash’s devastating turn is captured in the words, “Immediately, he [Cain] rose up against him and killed him.”


In Toldot, that danger returns. Esav resolves, “I will kill my brother Jacob” (Genesis 27:41). Yet this time Rivkah intervenes, sending Jacob away before the threatened murder can occur (27:42–45).


The Arizal’s teaching also explicitly connects Esav with Cain, deepening the traditional basis for this comparison. The mission of Am Yisrael and the key to their survival required that they take on the external qualities of strength, daring and boldness—positive attributes of the red-headed Esau.


Jacob becomes Israel, motivated by a sacred mission to found a holy nation that speaks words from the Torah while clothed in physical power and boldness--attributes later embodied in the red-headed King David. God gives us our talents and abilities. We can choose to elevate those gifts, in service to God and humanity.

 
 
 

Related Posts

See All
A Dream of Kingdoms

According to Rashi, Jacob was 77 years old when he departed from Beersheva and headed toward Padan Aram to find a wife. Genesis 28 describes him stopping for the night at a place that Jewish tradition

 
 
 
Sarah: Woman of Valor

Parashat Chayei Sarah (Gen. 23:1–25:18) records the death and burial of Sarah. The text gives her age at the time of her passing in a curious way: “Sarah's lifetime—the span of Sarah's life—came to 12

 
 
 
The Tie That Binds

In Parashat Vayeira (Genesis 18:1-22:24), God never commanded Abraham to slaughter Isaac. The text says to,” bring him up, to offer him”. It was Abraham's supreme test of obedience, but a deeper readi

 
 
 

Comments


Jerusalem Lights, Inc. is a 501 (C) 3 non-profit American organization which aids in support of Rabbi Richman's educational and outreach projects.  All donations made by US citizens are tax-deductible.

QUICK LINKS
 

Contact Us

​

Podcast

​

Weekly Classes

​

Video Archives

​

Blog​​​

  • Whatsapp
  • Spotify
  • White Facebook Icon
  • White YouTube Icon

In the USA: Jerusalem Lights Inc. 

Post Office Box 16886 

Lubbock Texas 79490

In Israel: Jerusalem Lights 

Rabbi Chaim Richman 

PO Box 23808 

Jerusalem, 9123701 Israel

light-1551386_640.jpg

This website is dedicated in loving memory of Grace Elizabeth Specht 

(c) 2026 Rabbi Chaim Richman

  Proudly Created in Jerusalem  Israel 

bottom of page